This website uses cookies

We use cookies to enhance your experience and support COUNTER Metrics for transparent reporting of readership statistics. Cookie data is not sold to third parties or used for marketing purposes.

Skip to main content
null
Findings
  • Menu
  • Articles
    • Energy Findings
    • Resilience Findings
    • Safety Findings
    • Transport Findings
    • Urban Findings
    • All
  • For Authors
  • Editorial Board
  • About
  • Blog
  • search
  • X (formerly Twitter) (opens in a new tab)
  • LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)
  • RSS feed (opens a modal with a link to feed)

RSS Feed

Enter the URL below into your favorite RSS reader.

https://findingspress.org/feed
ISSN 2652-8800
Transport Findings
November 21, 2026 AEST

Does Opening a Regional Express Rail Line Increase Excess Commuting? Evidence from Seoul, Korea

Jae Hyun Lee, Ph.D., Scott Hardman, Ph.D., Jungyeon Yi, Ph.D.,
excess commutingregional express railnew townscommutingresidential sortingmobile phone dataSeoul
Copyright Logoccby-sa-4.0 • https://doi.org/10.32866/001c.175189
Findings
Lee, Jae Hyun, Scott Hardman, and Jungyeon Yi. 2026. “Does Opening a Regional Express Rail Line Increase Excess Commuting? Evidence from Seoul, Korea.” Findings, November 20. https://doi.org/10.32866/001c.175189.
Save article as...▾
Download all (3)
  • Figure 1. Excess commuting relative to each district’s own pre-opening level.
    Download
  • Figure 2. Where commuting shifted.
    Download
  • Download

Error

Sorry, something went wrong. Please try again.

If this problem reoccurs, please contact Scholastica Support

Error message:

undefined

View more stats

Abstract

GTX is an express rail line from Seoul’s suburbs to its center. Using mobile phone data, we measure how excess commuting changed after its northern section opened, in two steps: with the minimum commute computed from pre-opening numbers of resident workers and jobs, then from each month’s own. Paju’s commuters, at the line’s northern end, took farther jobs toward Yongsan and Gangnam’s business district. Excess distance rose 5.9 and 5.3 points, each the largest among 45 districts, or 1.5 to 5.0 net of the pre-opening trend. At actual travel times excess time did not rise; commute time rose 1.2 minutes.

1. QUESTIONS

Around Seoul, suburbanization has accelerated through new town development, and commuting into the city has increased, making congestion worse. GTX (Great Train eXpress, top speed 180 km/h; Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport 2024) is an attempt to address this through expanding public transport. A faster line changes travel in and out of the suburbs, including commuting. Excess commuting measures how inefficient that commuting is. Therefore, whether a faster line shortens commuting or lets commuters reach farther jobs can be measured by excess commuting: the distance or time by which a district’s commuting goes beyond what the locations of homes and jobs require (Hamilton 1982; Ma and Banister 2006a; White 1988).

GTX-A, the first GTX line, opened its northern section on 28 December 2024. Paju district, at the northern end of the line, has a new town, Unjeong, which is still growing: the town’s population grew from 268,000 in 2023 to 303,000 in 2025 (Ministry of the Interior and Safety 2026; Supplemental Information). The GTX-A station opened inside the town, and the line cut the trip to Seoul Station from 46 minutes by rail and 66 by express bus to 22 minutes (Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport 2024). Paju therefore offers a unique opportunity to observe the two changes that move excess commuting at the same time: the opening changed travel times to Seoul on one day, and the new town keeps changing the locations of homes and jobs as it fills with new residents. Many studies have followed how excess commuting changes over time (Chen et al. 2023; Ma and Banister 2006b, 2007; Murphy 2016; Yang 2008; Zhou and Murphy 2019). However, no study has measured what the opening of a fast rail line does to excess commuting. In this paper, we ask whether excess commuting at Paju changed, in distance or in time, how it evolved month by month, and where the added commuting goes. We measure the excess in two steps: with the numbers of resident workers and jobs in each zone held at their pre-opening levels, so that only a change in where commuters work can move the excess, and then with those numbers following each month, so that the minimum commute follows new residents and their workplaces as well.

2. METHODS

The data are the Seoul capital region’s de facto population mobility data (Seoul Metropolitan Government and KT 2025): daily origin–destination flows inferred from mobile network signals, each with an inferred trip purpose. In mobile phone data generally, purpose is inferred more accurately for commuting than for other trips, because home and work are regularly located day by day (Abdi et al. 2026). We use work trips by domestic residents for Tuesday to Thursday during one mid-month week per month, January 2023 to December 2025.

Excess commuting is measured against the transportation problem (White 1988). Let Oi be the resident workers of zone i (Seoul’s 426 dong, its neighbourhood zones, and the 52 districts outside Seoul; Supplemental Information), Dj the jobs taken in zone j, mijt the observed commuters from zone i to zone j in month t, and cij the pair’s mean reported distance (or time) in 2023, before any GTX section opened. The least-cost assignment x minimises

\[ \Sigma_i \Sigma_j x_{i j} c_{i j} \quad \text { subject to } \quad \Sigma_j x_{i j}=O_i, \quad \Sigma_i x_{i j}=D_j, \quad x_{i j} \geqslant 0 . \]

We solve it in two steps. In the first step Oi and Dj are their 2024 means and the assignment is solved once, so that only a change in where commuters work can move the excess. In the second step Oi and Dj are each month’s own, so that the minimum commute follows new residents and their workplaces as well. Excess at origin i in month t is

\[ E_{i t}=\Sigma_j m_{i j t} c_{i j} / \Sigma_j m_{i j t}-\Sigma_j x_{i j} c_{i j} / O_i, \]

that month’s actual mean commute less the minimum commute. An origin’s minimum commute is its share of this region-wide assignment. We confirmed that this assignment has a unique solution in every month (Supplemental Information). Excess time is measured at 2023 travel times, which reflect only the mix of destinations, and at actual travel times, those reported for each month, which also reflect faster travel (the assignment solved again each month).

Outside Seoul the capital region has 52 districts, six with GTX-A stations; we report Paju. The comparison group is the remaining 46 less two whose pre-opening excess was not positive, leaving 44 districts. Because the level of excess depends on zone size (Small and Song 1992), each estimate is Paju’s own change in excess, in percent of its pre-opening level, less the change in the comparison districts’ median, twelve months after the opening against twelve months before. Its 95% interval comes from a moving-block bootstrap of the monthly gaps between Paju’s excess and the comparison median, both in percent of their pre-opening levels, and p from the estimate’s rank in absolute value among all 45 districts (Supplemental Information). The interval measures how precisely the twelve-month difference is estimated from the month-to-month variation of Paju’s gap; p asks whether Paju’s estimate is significantly different from those of the districts without a station.

3. FINDINGS

Figure 1A shows that Paju’s excess distance rose in both steps. With the numbers of resident workers and jobs in each zone held fixed, it rose 5.9 points of its pre-opening level against the comparison median (95% interval 2.3 to 8.9), and this rise was the largest among the 45 districts (p = 0.022). With those numbers following each month, it rose 5.3 points (95% interval 2.4 to 7.7), and this rise was also the largest, although one comparison district’s fall was larger in absolute value (p = 0.044): the minimum commute rose only 0.017 km, so the two steps give nearly the same distance. Paju’s gap from the comparison median was already widening before the opening, by 0.37 points a month over 2024 and 0.10 over 2023 and 2024 in the first step and by 0.22 and 0.06 in the second; projecting each step’s own drift through the post-opening year leaves 1.5 and 4.9 of the first step’s 5.9 points (p = 0.58 and 0.067) and 2.6 and 5.0 of the second step’s 5.3 (p = 0.51 and 0.13), so the rise is a post-opening association of 1.5 to 5.9 points depending on the trend assumed (Supplemental Information). Excess time at actual travel times fell in both steps, 8.6 points in the first and 16.6 in the second, neither significantly different from the comparison districts (p = 0.27 and 0.18). It fell more in the second step because resident workers grew faster than jobs, so the minimum commute rose about 1 minute. At 2023 travel times, which hold speeds fixed, excess time rose in the first step (+6.2 points, p = 0.022) and fell in the second (−3.2 points, not significantly different from the comparison districts, p = 0.40), again because the minimum commute rose (Supplemental Information). Figure 1B shows that before the opening Paju’s excess was below the median of the 45 districts, in distance (5.0 km against 5.5) and in time at actual travel times (12.9 minutes in the first step against 15.6). Figure 1C shows that Paju alone combines a large rise in excess distance with a fall in excess time, in both steps.

Figure 1
Figure 1.Excess commuting relative to each district’s own pre-opening level.

Note. (A) Month by month at Paju, in two steps: left, the numbers of resident workers and jobs in each zone held at their pre-opening levels; right, those numbers following each month. Rows: excess distance, with pair distances fixed at their 2023 means, and excess time at actual travel times. Blue, Paju (dots, each month; line, three-month moving average); grey line and band, the median and 10th–90th percentile range of the 44 districts without a station in the same step (in the time row the band is shown only between index values 70 and 130). The labels give the twelve-month estimates: own change less the comparison median’s, in points of the pre-opening level, with the moving-block bootstrap 95% interval and the rank-based p. (B) Levels over the twelve months before the opening, in the same two steps. (C) Own change over the twelve months after the opening less the comparison median’s, both in percent of own level, in the same two steps; the shaded quadrant is farther but not longer, and comparison districts beyond the axis limits are shown at the edge (open diamonds).

Figure 2 counts observed commutes, which are the same in both steps. Figure 2A shows that the added commuting goes to longer distances: commutes below 10 km grew only 3.0%, while those beyond 40 km grew 13.7%. Commuting to Seoul grew 9.5% against a comparison median of 1.1%. The growth was as much within 3 km of the open stations, Seoul Station and Yeonsinnae (10.1%), as beyond 3 km (9.4%). The strongest increases on the map are at the Yongsan business district beside Seoul Station and at Yeouido, the financial district (Figure 2B). Growth was fastest toward the Gangnam business district, which the line does not directly reach yet: commuting within 3 km of Samseong or Suseo station grew 19.1% against a comparison median of 1.7%. The actual travel time from Paju to that area fell 7.1 minutes against 0.3 from the comparison districts pooled, as a first leg by GTX⁠⁠-A would produce; the data do not record route or mode (Supplemental Information).

Figure 2
Figure 2.Where commuting shifted.

Note. Observed commutes, the same in both steps. (A) Change in weekday commutes by distance band, twelve months after the opening against twelve months before, pair distances fixed at their 2023 means, for Paju and the median of the 44 districts without a station. (B) Kernel density of the change in arrivals of Paju’s commuters within Seoul, January to December 2025 against the twelve months before, every Tuesday to Thursday outside holidays (all weeks, not only the mid-month week used in the text), with Paju’s total commuting held at its pre-opening level: blue, destinations that gained share; red, those that grew more slowly than the district average. The four small panels show the same change for each quarter of 2025 against the twelve months before the opening, on the same colour scale. Blue outline, Paju; dashed rings, straight-line distance from Paju’s GTX-A station at 20, 30, 40 and 50 km; orange, GTX-A, dotted where not yet open; circles, stations, named within Seoul; light blue, the Unjeong new town; grey italics, areas named in the text.

After the opening, the mean commute distance of Paju’s commuters grew 2.9 points of its pre-opening level against the comparison median, and this rise was the largest among the 45 districts (p = 0.022). The change in their mean commute time was not significant (+1.2 minutes; +2.2 points against the comparison median, 95% interval −1.0 to +5.2, p = 0.24; Supplemental Information), so the evidence is stronger for a change in where commuters work than for a change in how long their trips take. These results are consistent with previous studies on travel time, which found that at the aggregate level trip distances grow with travel speeds while travel times remain stable (Levinson and Kumar 1994; Mokhtarian and Chen 2004). In addition, excess commuting shows that, in distance, the added commuting goes beyond what the locations of Paju’s homes and jobs require. The data are monthly flows, not people, so existing residents changing jobs cannot be distinguished from new residents taking farther ones; but Unjeong filled as fast in 2024 as in 2025 and Paju’s commuter count did not grow significantly faster than the comparison districts (Supplemental Information).


ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The authors designed the study, carried out the analysis, and take responsibility for the content. Anthropic Claude and OpenAI Codex assisted with drafting, code, and consistency checks; the authors independently verified all analytical decisions, code, and interpretations.

DATA AND CODE

The mobility data are open data of the Seoul Metropolitan Government (Seoul Open Data Plaza, dataset OA-22300). A single R script that downloads the sampled days and reproduces every result computed from the mobility data in the text and in the Supplemental Information, and Figure 1 and Figure S2, is available at https://github.com/knugislee1/gtx-excess-commuting (Supplemental Information, S5).

CONFLICT OF INTEREST

The authors declare no conflict of interest. No external funding supported this work.

Submitted: September 06, 2026 AEST

Accepted: November 06, 2026 AEST

References

Abdi, A., A. Delbosc, and G. Rose. 2026. “Bridging the Gap in Passive Mobility Big Data: A Methodological Systematic Review of Activity and Trip Purpose Inference.” Expert Systems with Applications 328: 132845. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1016/​j.eswa.2026.132845.
Google Scholar
Chen, R., M. Zhang, and J. Zhou. 2023. “Jobs-Housing Relationships before and amid COVID-19: An Excess-Commuting Approach.” Journal of Transport Geography 106: 103507. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1016/​j.jtrangeo.2022.103507.
Google ScholarPubMed CentralPubMed
Hamilton, B. W. 1982. “Wasteful Commuting.” Journal of Political Economy 90 (5): 1035–53. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1086/​261107.
Google Scholar
Levinson, D. M., and A. Kumar. 1994. “The Rational Locator: Why Travel Times Have Remained Stable.” Journal of the American Planning Association 60 (3): 319–32. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1080/​01944369408975590.
Google Scholar
Ma, K. R., and D. Banister. 2006a. “Excess Commuting: A Critical Review.” Transport Reviews 26 (6): 749–67. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1080/​01441640600782609.
Google Scholar
Ma, K. R., and D. Banister. 2006b. “Extended Excess Commuting: A Measure of the Jobs-Housing Imbalance in Seoul.” Urban Studies 43 (11): 2099–113. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1080/​00420980600945245.
Google Scholar
Ma, K. R., and D. Banister. 2007. “Urban Spatial Change and Excess Commuting.” Environment and Planning A 39 (3): 630–46. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1068/​a37441.
Google Scholar
Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport. 2024. “Paju–Seoul chultoegeun 20-bundae, GTX⁠‑A Unjeongjungang–Seoul-yeok 28-il gaetong [Paju–Seoul commutes in the twenties of minutes: GTX‑A Unjeongjungang–Seoul Station section opens on the 28th].” Press release. Korea Policy Briefing, December 27. https:/​/​www.korea.kr/​docViewer/​result/​2024.12/​27/​3da94f6a4edfbc71814cfee14e3016fd/​3da94f6a4edfbc71814cfee14e3016fd.view.xhtml.
Ministry of the Interior and Safety. 2026. “Haengjeongdongbyeol jumin deungnok ingu mit sedae hyeonhwang [Resident registration population and households by administrative dong].” Statistics portal. https:/​/​jumin.mois.go.kr/​.
Mokhtarian, P. L., and C. Chen. 2004. “TTB or Not TTB, That Is the Question: A Review and Analysis of the Empirical Literature on Travel Time (and Money) Budgets.” Transportation Research Part A 38 (9–10): 643–75. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1016/​j.tra.2003.12.004.
Google Scholar
Murphy, E. 2016. “Excess Commuting and Commuting Economy: Peak and off-Peak Variation in Travel Efficiency Measures.” In Traffic Management, edited by S. Cohen and G. Yannis. Wiley. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1002/​9781119307822.ch17.
Google Scholar
Seoul Metropolitan Government and KT. 2025. “Sudogwon saenghwal idong deiteo maenyueol [De facto population mobility data manual for the Seoul metropolitan area].” Seoul Open Data Plaza. https:/​/​data.seoul.go.kr/​dataList/​OA-22300/​F/​1/​datasetView.do.
Small, K. A., and S. Song. 1992. “‘Wasteful’ Commuting: A Resolution.” Journal of Political Economy 100 (4): 888–98. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1086/​261844.
Google Scholar
White, M. J. 1988. “Urban Commuting Journeys Are Not ‘Wasteful.’” Journal of Political Economy 96 (5): 1097–110. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1086/​261579.
Google Scholar
Yang, J. 2008. “Policy Implications of Excess Commuting: Examining the Impacts of Changes in US Metropolitan Spatial Structure.” Urban Studies 45 (2): 391–405. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1177/​0042098007085969.
Google Scholar
Zhou, J., and E. Murphy. 2019. “Day-to-Day Variation in Excess Commuting: An Exploratory Study of Brisbane, Australia.” Journal of Transport Geography 74: 223–32. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1016/​j.jtrangeo.2018.11.014.
Google Scholar

Attachments

Powered by Scholastica, the modern academic journal management system